I have sent to that supplied E-Mail address, the following, with my full name and address redacted here:
Dear Councilman Stokes: I read, online at the EMT City.com web site, about your disagreement with the AMR Ambulance Service Providers in your area. In potentially violent situations, if I understand the gist of your statements, the crews should simply don "soft body armor", and respond in. As someone who has been working ambulances in the volunteer, proprietary, and municipal areas for 38 years, 25 years with the Fire Department of New York City Emergency Medical Service Command (recently retired), I find such attitude to truly be shocking. One of the first things taught to EMTs and Paramedics is what is called "Scene Safety". On arrival at a scene, the crews will do a quick "10 Second Scene Safety Survey", which includes looking for downed wires, obviously unstable things like trees and telephone poles overhanging car wrecks, flaming buildings, and people, other than Law Enforcement Officers or the Military, brandishing firearms or knives. Those in EMS are not usually trained in hand to hand combat by their employers, as is the case with the LEOs. Also, if needed, LEOs are carrying firearms of their own, to shoot back if necessary. EMS crews are trained in helping the sick and injured, not in causing some of the injuries they might treat. If an Emergency Medical Technician or Paramedic gets hurt or killed at a violent scene, or on any assignment, they are not available to respond to help anyone else. In addition, a second crew will be needed to respond to the injured first crew, and a third to the original incident. While the second ambulance is leap-frogging over the area covered by the first crew, and the third over both the previous crews, who is going to cover the areas they left while helping at the first crew's scene? I admit that there are specialty trained "Tactical EMS" teams, who respond in to scenes with the SWAT or Hostage Negotiating Teams, or cross trained LEOs who serve in EMS capacity when in the special response. However, as with the US Military, most times, the "medic" is unarmed, and is protected by the armed LEOs (or the Army or Marine unit they are with). The Tactical EMS crews train regularly with the LEOs, which most "line unit" EMS crews do not do. Before you just tell an EMS crew to don the armor, I would suggest you ride a few tours in ambulances that cover areas in Jackson, or any large metropolitan area, known to be prone to violence on Saturday nights. I think that doing so might open your eyes. Respectfully, Richard B, New York State Emergency Medical Technician, FDNY EMS Command (Retired).