what a great and stimulating topic. Just when I think I know what I think, you guys get me going. Who was it who said that a conclusion is something you come to when you are tired of thinking?
I don't believe that God gives simplistic answers to complex issues. This whole issue of what the bible really means is a valid one. Whether it's upbringing, or personal inclination, life experiences, etc. something brings us to our own understanding of the universe and our place in it. Our world view, as well as our practice of the divine is one of the things that makes us uniquely human. We all have some kind of "religion", some encoded in doctrine and organized churches, others not. We are meant to struggle with these issues. We are designed to balance the needs of the child with the needs of the community. I value the strength of commitment that JWs generally display, but I disagree with what I believe is faulty scholarship and indoctrinational isolation. That not withstanding, my place of regular worship has demonstrated errors in doctrine that will be extremely challenging to address. The key is that these doctrinal errors be corrected. The study of the bible without an understanding of languages, cultures, historical development, etc. along with the guidance of the Holy Spirit will produce erroneous conclusions.
The bottom line for me is the preservation of life and you bet, I will do everything in my power to convince the parents of a child to allow standard of care - BUT I am not God and if I fail, then it was not my call.
Thanks for the great discussion