You know, I remember one of the ones on Traumacentral. I was all pissed off about it because I was a wet behind the ears basic (pet peeve: EMT-P, EMT-B both EMTs. I'd rather be called "just a basic" then "just an EMT") and thought the same. After working part time (full time college student), I realize there is a problem.
Ok, preface, I work for probably the world's worse IFT company. Hey, they pay the most and are willing to work with my schedule.
(Dust, read the whole post before commenting, we all know you're views on IFTs)
There is a problem with a basic who think they can do discharges with a patient on a albuterol breathing treatment because they didn't start it (medico-legal/scope).
There is a problem when a basic call for an ALS unit when they are 0.4 miles away from one of the best hospitals in the area (500+ beds, ER almost never closes), thus delaying both ALS and definitive care (protocol education).
There is a problem when basics think that the trendelenburg position is great for a patients BP but has never heard the term "starling effect." (education problem)
There is a problem when the basic training is 120 hours, mostly based on trauma (come on, most of the work is medical to begin with). Even then, I could have sworn I learnt over half this stuff as a boy scout. (education and emphasis problem)
There is a problem when basics want to use [insert random gizmo, pulse ox is the favorite here] yet have no idea what would give you a false reading and/or think it is a hypoxia detector (grant it, based on a recent post, this last one is popular with ALS at times as well [*cough* cyanide affects cytocrome C, not oxygen saturation])
I personally, feel educated enough for BLS. By educated, I mean almost 3 years of college level courses [biochem, genetics, upper division cell bio, upper division physiology, etc] that backs up the very basic and almost useless information given to me in my basic class. I know that I've diverted to closer hospitals because of my education or hospital volunteering experiences. Unfortunately, from what I have seen on this and other boards I seem to be the exception rather then the rule for BLS.
If I had my way, EMT-Basic would become EMT-IFT. No lights, no sirens. Just a van, a gurney, a tank of O2, and some isolation supplies. This is the minimum standard to take granny for dialysis or do that hospice discharge.
EMT-I is the new EMT-Basic, minimum staffing level on an ambulance. Someone who can do more then say, "Here’s a NRB."
If California had widespread use of intermediates, I would have highly considered it. Unfortunately, most parts of California is basic or paramedic (and where I am, paramedic=fire department).